This is our old Q&A Site. Please post any new questions and answers at ask.wireshark.org.

Hello promiscuous doesn't seem to work, i can only see broadcast and and packets addressed to me,I use an alfa adapter, with chipset 8187L, when i use wireshark with promiscuous mode, and then use netstat -i, i can't see that "p" flag, and if i spoof another device i can see his packets help me please, I need it in my work "I'm a student"

asked 25 Mar '16, 08:04

Salim%20Bitam's gravatar image

Salim Bitam
6112
accept rate: 0%

OS and Wireshark version?

(25 Mar '16, 08:09) grahamb ♦

I use last version of wireshark, i tried with ubuntu, kali linux 1 && 2, Is it true that, to sniff on wireless network, only monitor mod works, not promiscuous?

(25 Mar '16, 08:17) Salim Bitam

Have you read the wiki page on wireless capture?

(25 Mar '16, 09:19) grahamb ♦

Yes sir trust me I did, i spent 15 days searching how to solve this problem, but i can't :/ , I even asked experimented persons, they told me that they use only monitor mod

(25 Mar '16, 09:23) Salim Bitam

I made my AP open, and when i capture with wireshark, i disconnect everyone first, but still doesn't work

(25 Mar '16, 09:25) Salim Bitam

Can you explain why do you need to use exactly promiscuous mode on a wireless card, given that you know that on many (if not most) wireless cards it does not work the same like on wired Ethernet? What makes monitoring mode unacceptable for your purpose?

(25 Mar '16, 13:16) sindy

Yes, I need to make it work on promiscuous to be able to detect NICs on promiscuous mode

(25 Mar '16, 13:23) Salim Bitam

So the submission of your work is "identify all NICs on the machine which are currently running in promiscuous mode", and the data captured in that mode are actually not so important and you only wanted to use their contents as a proof that the card is in promiscuous mode?

(25 Mar '16, 13:28) sindy

noo, i want to identify each device's NIC of my network if it's running in promiscuous mode

(25 Mar '16, 13:32) Salim Bitam

OK, so in a minimalistic case, you would have two machines. Machine A's NIC could be switched between normal and promiscuous mode, and machine B would run a software which would find out whether machine A's NIC is currently running promiscuous mode or not?

(25 Mar '16, 13:37) sindy

Thaaaat's it :) , my problem is I can't sniff with promiscuous mode, only monitor mode works, so Did it work for you without the monitor mode please, you would save my life

(25 Mar '16, 13:40) Salim Bitam

you would save my life

I'm afraid I'm not that powerful :-) The point is that if you really need this to work with wireless NICs, that goal is nearly impossible to obtain.

With wireless in general, promiscuous mode makes little sense: if encryption is used, each STA uses its individual session keys (even if built from a common pre-shared key) to encrypt the communication with the AP, so when STA's wireless adaptor receives a packet for another STA, it cannot decipher it. Therefore, even though you're right that without encryption (i.e. after making your AP open as you wrote) it could work, the wireless NIC drivers usually don't care much about promiscuous mode implementation, or simply do not support it at all.

So to test your solution on a wireless network, you'd have to find one of few wireless NIC models which do support promiscuous mode and install it into your machine A,

So I'd recommend you to take an Ethernet patchcord and fulfil the submission using wired Ethernet.

(25 Mar '16, 14:21) sindy

Okay Thank you a lot for your time :) I have a better idea now

(25 Mar '16, 14:23) Salim Bitam
showing 5 of 13 show 8 more comments

If you have read the capture page, then why the question whether you really need monitor mode to capture (foreign, non-data or not-to-you) traffic? [Btw, the answer is: Yes, you really do need monitor mode].

Can you please describe the exact steps you tried to do the capture?

permanent link

answered 27 Mar '16, 11:54

jmayer's gravatar image

jmayer
262
accept rate: 0%

Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Question tags:

×43
×19

question asked: 25 Mar '16, 08:04

question was seen: 1,416 times

last updated: 27 Mar '16, 11:54

p​o​w​e​r​e​d by O​S​Q​A